bonus
BONUS: Chief Seattle, Cultural Appropriation, and Native Legacies
In this bonus episode, we shed light on the historical significance of Chief Seattle while confronting the challenges of finding credible sources about Native American history. We explore how his voice has been filtered through settler perspectives, creating a shadowy figure in the archives, and discuss the cultural appropriation that often distorts Indigenous narratives.
As we navigate through the noise that surrounds Chief Seattle, we aim to uncover the real stories of Indigenous history, particularly in urban settings like Seattle, where the past continually resurfaces. Join us as we delve into the intertwined histories of Indigenous and settler communities and reflect on how those relationships evolve over time.
...
Special guest for this episode:
- Coll Thrush, a professor of history at the University of British Columbia, with a teaching focus on Indigenous and settler colonial histories. His books include the acclaimed Native Seattle.
...
Highlights from this episode:
- Chief Seattle remains a somewhat elusive figure, with historical records often filtered through settler perspectives.
- Urban and Indigenous histories are not mutually exclusive; they are intertwined and shape each other significantly.
- Cultural appropriation and the use of Native imagery in cities raise important questions about respect and representation.
- Indigenous communities in Washington have experienced a resurgence in culture and political presence over the last fifty years.
- Historical injustices, such as the treatment of Indigenous peoples in boarding schools, continue to impact present-day relations.
- Apologies for past wrongs, like those issued by political leaders, must be accompanied by meaningful actions to foster true reconciliation.
...
Additional Resources:
Native Seattle: Histories from the Crossing-Over Place by Coll Thrush
Chief Seattle and the Town That Took His Name: The Change of Worlds for the Native People and Settlers on Puget by David Buerge
Chief Seattle Speech | The Suquamish Tribe
What happened at the great battle at Maple Bay? – The Discourse
Treaty of Point Elliott, 1855 | GOIA
...
And if you like this episode, you might also love:
How Did Slavery Impact Cherokee Nation?
...
SUPPORT THE SHOW
Individual Supporters: https://america-a-history.captivate.fm/support
University Partners: https://america-a-history.captivate.fm/partnerships
Brand Sponsors: liam@mercurypodcasts.com
Contact us: america@podcastsbyliam.com
We're partnering with NeoTaste, the exclusive membership card unlocking huge discounts at hundreds of restaurants across the UK & Europe. Get your first 2 months free by using the code AAH at checkout. Sign up here: https://neotaste.com/gb?code=AAH&a=2
Are you a University or college? Become an academic partner and your name will appear right here.
Mentioned in this episode:
This episode is sponsored by What's Your Map
What's Your Map is the British Podcast Award-winning show from map expert Professor Jerry Brotton. In each episode, he invites a special guest to share a map that means something to them. It's a fascinating show, and you can listen to the new season right now: https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/whats-your-map/id1766500219
Transcript
Hello, and welcome to this bonus episode of A History, recorded straight after our recently published episode. Who is Chief Seattle? I'm joined now by the guest from that episode, Cole Thrush, to discuss this a little bit more.
Cole, thank you so much for hanging on.
Coll Thrush:Of course.
Liam Heffernan:It was really great to talk to you in the podcast about Chief Seattle. There really isn't an awful lot about him, is there?
Coll Thrush:No, it's. For a figure that is so prominent and culturally significant, he is a bit of a shadow in the archives in many ways.
And when we do have his voice, it's often filtered through settler interlocutors. And he's a bit of a slippery figure in many ways. As important as he clearly was and still is, it can be a little bit hard to pin him down at times.
Liam Heffernan:Yeah, I. I do feel as though the same could be said for Native American history generally. You know, it can be very difficult to find credible sources of information. There's a lot of noise out there, isn't there?
Coll Thrush: he decades since his death in:And, you know, 100 years on from his death, people were still sort of embellishing the speech that's attributed to him with all kinds of other ideas that were not his.
And so, yeah, there's a lot to wade through, a lot of folklore to wade through, but there still is a real kernel of a really important historical person who was real and who did good work.
Liam Heffernan:Yeah. And, I mean, of course, credit has to go to people like yourselves for, you know, trying to present some sort of cohesive, you know, history.
And on that note, you know, tell me about your book.
Coll Thrush:Sure, yeah.
Over Place, was published in:And Indigenous histories, which are usually treated as though they're mutually exclusive. When urban history begins, Indigenous history ends, or that's the way the story is typically told.
And I really wanted to challenge that by showing how indigenous and urban histories are actually. They're not mutually exclusive. They're mutually constitutive. They create each other together. And a place like Seattle is a great place to do that.
Where you've got local people like the Duwamish, in whose territory the city grew up, you've got Native migrants to the city from all kinds of other places. And you've got uses of so called Indian imagery in the city. So what does it mean when a city sells itself using a totem pole as its symbol?
What does that say about settler society? So it's a really rich place to do this kind of work. And the book has had a really good life, largely without me, and we'll.
Liam Heffernan:Link to that in the show notes as well, so people can check that out. And I do wonder, though, that you have to think that when.
When, you know, skyscrapers are built and when cities are constructed, that actually there has to be an adverse effect on the people that lived on that land. So surely the settler's gain is a loss to the indigenous, right?
Coll Thrush:Yeah, and that was definitely true in Seattle.
inside of the downtown in the:But one of the things about urban history is that cities always dig up their own past. And so indigenous history has never been fully absent in the city. It's always been there.
Whether it's ancestral remains being disturbed or a place name being used or whatever. There's so many opportunities for indigenous history to kind of reawaken.
Liam Heffernan:And actually, you know, we touched a little bit on cultural appropriation in the main episode.
But thinking about that and what you've just said, Washington perhaps gets more of a spotlight on things like that, because in recent years, you've seen, you know, the football team, the Washington get renamed, because obviously that was. That was just a bad choice.
And, you know, there's other examples of, you know, I mean, we've just talked about Seattle, but actually in the main episode, we.
We kind of highlighted how the relationship between native and settler communities was perhaps more positive compared to, you know, the national average, I should say. So was it. Was it meant out of disrespect? When, particularly when people in Washington name things after Native people?
Coll Thrush:It really depends. I mean, the case of the Washington football team, that's. It's just a racist. Racist epithet. Yeah. There's no question there.
The R word is as bad as it gets.
Liam Heffernan:Yeah.
Coll Thrush:And it's an inherently violent term. And then you have things like, you know, communities that in their high schools, they use mascots like the savages or the Indians or whatever.
And all of those are kind of predicated on the idea that real indigenous people are either gone or no longer authentic. And so in that process, these metaphors become kind of free floating and non indigenous people think that they're just free for the taking.
And so all of these mascot ideas are sort of dependent upon the idea that Indigenous people are going to disappear and just become symbols.
Liam Heffernan:Yeah, it's a great point. So, I mean, in summary, no should not be done. Which is good thinking.
Again, sort of more present day, what is that relationship like between Native communities and. And non Native communities, particularly in Washington State?
Coll Thrush:Yeah, well, I mean, there's been over the last half century, a massive resurgence of Indigenous culture and politics and law in Washington state, in the Seattle area in particular. And so, for example, now the major sports teams in Seattle are sponsored by area tribes, or at least federally recognized tribes.
When you come ashore on the ferry into downtown Seattle, there are Coast Salish welcoming figures welcoming you to the city. It's very much a part of the fabric of the city and of the region.
That doesn't mean there's no controversy, but Indigenous communities are extremely prominent now.
And even in the case of the Duwamish, who are not federally recognized, they still have a lot of cultural prominence in the city, in part because of their connection to Chief Seattle.
Liam Heffernan:Yeah. And so how, how integrated are Native communities? You know, I'm thinking kind of, you know, the ancestors of.
Of these tribes that some of whom probably stayed in the. These sort of urban centers. And you said sort of married into, you know, settler communities. Is there. Is there still much separation between them?
Coll Thrush:It sort of depends. I mean, that's always the, the historian's answer, right? It depends.
But, you know, there are lots of places where indigenous and settler communities are really integrated with each other. There are a lot of places where they aren't. I grew up at the edge of a reservation, and it was a very segregated place.
This is back in the:So it's really changed in those last, you know, in the course of my lifetime.
Liam Heffernan:Yeah. And funnily enough, we had a conversation towards the start of this year, actually, about the, the boarding schools.
the fact that, you know, it's:And it really kind of highlights just how far there still is to go in that relationship.
Coll Thrush: ial school closed in the late:And, you know, that kind of history has implications that echo down the generations. And so we have to really think about intergenerational trauma, particularly when it's not. Not acknowledged by wider society at all.
And so that's a larger process that Canada has. Has been dealing with through the Truth and Reconciliation Commission.
But the US has just never really addressed in a meaningful way, an apology is not enough.
Liam Heffernan:Yeah, absolutely. Anyone can give an apology. Right.
Coll Thrush:It's just a word, but it's meaningful. But it's not enough.
Liam Heffernan:Yeah, exactly. Exactly. And, you know, on that note, there's still a lot more to talk about on the podcast, and we're going to.
I mean, one thing that we've really tried to make a concerted effort of is to.
Is to cover Native history as much as possible, and we'll continue to do so on the podcast because that is obviously an incredibly important part of North American history as well.
So, Carl, I can't thank you enough for joining me to continue that discussion and talk about Chief Seattle and remind everyone where they can get in touch with you.
Coll Thrush:Okay. Yeah, they can find me@colthrush.com and also through the University of British Columbia. I'm pretty findable.
Liam Heffernan:Great. Yeah, thank you. And thanks again for joining the podcast.
Coll Thrush:Of course.
Liam Heffernan:It's been a pleasure.
For any listeners that want to know more, there'll be information in the show notes, links to everything we've mentioned, and do make sure as well that you follow the podcast. And if you do really love what we do, you can support us as well.
All the information is in the show notes, but thank you all so much for listening, and goodbye.
